LIFE STAGE

 

CASE STUDY

 

Preconception 1. Heather & Ian.
Pregnancy & Perinatal Period

 

1. Tom & Louise.

2. Emily.

3. Sivia.

4.Mara.

 

Infancy

 

1. Joe.

2. Chloe.

3. Ellie.

 

Childhood & Adolescence

 

1. Jasmine.

2. Janie.

3. James.

 

Adult 1

 

1. Bob & Carol.

2. Cathy.

3. Dennis.

 

Adult 2

 

1. Gordon.

2. Eleanor

 

 

PRECONCEPTION

 

1. Heather & Ian.

Ethical Issues:
Pregnancy management issues (eg. termination) may arise if a NTD is indicated from triple blood test or diagnosed during ultrasound. Anencephaly is not compatible with life but spina bifida is not necessarily life-threatening, depending on the severity of the defect.

Legal Issues:

 

Social Issues:

back to Heather & Ian

 

PREGNANCY & PERINATAL PERIOD

 

1. Tom & Louise.

Ethical Issues:

Pregnancy management issues (eg. termination) may arise if XYY is diagnosed prenatally during amniocentesis or chorionic villus sampling. As there is a variable outcome for each individual with this condition, it is not known how seriously affected each foetus will be.

Legal Issues:

Social Issues:
Excess physical energy during childhood should be directed into play, sports or other physical activities. Early theories that the XYY genotype predisposed males to criminal tendencies have been shown to be invalid.

back to Tom & Louise

 

2. Emily.

Ethical Issues:
Pregnancy management issues (eg. termination) may arise if trisomy 21 is diagnosed prenatally. As there is a variable outcome for each individual with Down syndrome, it is not known how seriously affected each foetus will be.

Legal Issues:

Social Issues:
For families with a known balanced translocation for trisomy 21, reproductive options include:
1. natural conception
2. prenatal diagnosis
3. pre-implantation genetic diagnosis
4. gamete donation
5. adoption.

back to Emily

3. Sivia

Ethical Issues:

Some forms of EDS may be misdiagnosed as child abuse (due to splitting of the skin, bruising, haematomas etc.) Reproductive decisions may be difficult due to the autosomal dominant mode of inheritance and the very limited availability of prenatal diagnosis (only possible if the mutation responsible has been identified).

Legal Issues:

Disclosure of Ehlers-Danlos syndrome for life/health insurance purposes will be necessary.

Social Issues:

For those with vascular EDS, pregnancy is associated with a high risk due to premature rupture of fetal membranes or rupture of the uterus. Social stigmatization may occur, particularly when there is disfigurement due to severe scarring. Shortened life expectancy is possible in the vascular type of EDS. life-style adjustments may be advisable, especially for children - there needs to be a balance between the benefit of less frequent injuries and the disadvantages of over-protection from parents/guardians.

Psychological problems may arise due to chronic pain and disability, fear of significant and painful skin ruptures, unemployment or restriction of lifestyle due to symptoms such as joint hypermobility, fragile skin etc.

Back to Sivia

4. Mara

Ethical Issues:
It is important to note that many people carrying this gene may be asymptomatic or have very mild symptoms but can still pass the condition on to their children - who could have more severe symptoms than their parents. In Type 1 vWD, the condition is often not diagnosed at all unless an individual has excessive bleeding following surgery, during or after childbirth, or a major accident. Disclosure to relatives may be an issue for affected individuals. However, testing of family members can help to identify the type of vWD and will also identify any family members carrying the mutated gene. This information will enable affected family members to access appropriate health care in the future. For an explanation of the way vWD is inherited see: http://www.haemophilia.org.za/Vonherit.htm

Legal Issues:

Disclosure of vWD status for life/health insurance purposes will be necessary.

Social Issues:
For women with Type 1 vWD, there may be life-style issues associated with heavy periods (menorrhagia).
Women with Type 1 vWD do not typically have problems during pregnancy. However they may need their levels of clotting factor VIII measured at delivery and for two weeks afterwards to ensure that levels of this molecule are adequate. This intervention may act to cause extra stress in the postnatal period. Parents with a newly diagnosed child (but who were unaware that they were carriers) may experience emotional problems such as shock, guilt, anger and fear with regard to the diagnosis of vWD and will require additional support at this time.

Back to Mara

 

INFANCY

1. Joe.

Ethical Issues:

Legal Issues:

Social Issues:

Possible confusion with physical abuse in children. http://www.ornl.gov/sci/techresources/Human_Genome/elsi/elsi.shtml

back to Joe

 

2. Chloe.

Ethical Issues:
Whether to share genetic information within and/or beyond the family. See the following article in the British Medical Journal: http://bmj.bmjjournals.com/cgi/content/full/329/7458/165?etoc

Legal Issues:

Social Issues:
For families with a known balanced translocation, reproductive options include:
1. natural conception
2. prenatal diagnosis
3. pre-implantation genetic diagnosis
4. gamete donation
5. adoption

http://www.ornl.gov/sci/techresources/Human_Genome/elsi/elsi.shtml

back to Chloe

3. Ellie.

Ethical Issues:

Pre-natal screening tests result in pregnancy management issues. Genetic screening as an adult can result in reproductive dilemmas.

Legal Issues:

Social Issues:
Physiotherapy and medical management of cystic fibrosis are life-long activities. Life expectancy typically 30 years.

back to Ellie

 

CHILDHOOD & ADOLESCENCE

 

1. Jasmine.

Ethical Issues:

Legal Issues:

Social Issues:
Obsessive behaviour (eg perseveration) can be a challenging aspect of the Prader-Willi syndrome. Strict dietary management strategies are also difficult to implement.

http://www.ornl.gov/sci/techresources/Human_Genome/elsi/elsi.shtml

back to Jasmine

 

2. Janie.

Ethical Issues:

If mother is a known carrier for DMD, then pre-natal diagnosis of the condition may result in pregnancy management issues (ie. termination).

Legal Issues:

Social Issues:

Impact of bereavement on family due to death of youth or young adult.
Genetic counselling for female family members who may be carriers.

back to Janie

 

 

3. James.

Ethical Issues:

Pre-natal screening is available for some forms of RP, which may result in pregnancy management issues.

Legal Issues:

Declaration or concealment of condition on insurance forms.

Social Issues:

Deteriorating vision will impact on ability to carry out normal day to day tasks, eg. driving, which will affect not only lifestyle but also potential careers.

back to James

 

 

ADULT 1

 

1. Bob & Carol.

Ethical Issues:
Whether to get tested for the condition if present in the family and then sharing/concealing this information from other family members, particularly offspring.

Legal Issues:
Declaring information on health/life insurance applications.

Social Issues:

Disease typically manifests in late 30s onwards, so individual may already have children before they know about their own condition.

Human Genome Project: http://www.ornl.gov/sci/techresources/Human_Genome/elsi/elsi.shtml

back to Bob & Carol

2. Cathy.

Ethical Issues:

Sharing information within the family regarding screening for genetic conditions.

Legal Issues:

Social Issues:

Chronic worry about developing breast cancer due to incidences of other cancers in the family. Vigilance and self-examination regarding one's own health and being able to discuss this with other family members and health professionals.

back to Cathy

 

3. Dennis.

Ethical Issues:

Whether to get screened for the condition if a hereditary risk is established.

Legal Issues:

Social Issues:

Regular medical check-ups are needed to determine current state of bowel health. A colostomy bag may be temporary or permanent; it can present many physical and social challenges for an individual and family to cope with.

back to Dennis

 

ADULT 2

 

1. Gordon.

Ethical Issues:

Whether to get tested for the condition if present in the family and then sharing/concealing this information from other family members, particularly offspring.

Legal Issues:

Declaring/concealing information on health and life insurance forms.

Social Issues:

Patients may already have children before they know about their own condition. Mental and physical deterioration may progress over many years, having a huge impact on the individual, family and friends.

http://www.ornl.gov/sci/techresources/Human_Genome/elsi/elsi.shtml

back to Gordon

 

2. Eleanor.

Ethical Issues:

Whether to get tested for the condition if present in the family and then sharing/concealing this information from other family members, particularly offspring.

Legal Issues:

Declaring information on health/life insurance applications.

Social Issues:

Disease typically manifests in late 30s onwards, so individual may already have children before they know about their own condition. End Stage Renal Disease (ESRD) means that kidney dialysis or a transplant are the only options for maintaining health; so large amounts of each week will be spent undergoing dialysis unless a kidney donor can be found. http://www.ornl.gov/sci/techresources/Human_Genome/elsi/elsi.shtml

back to Eleanor